Activity Report 2024-2026

In two years, Circular Materials and Chemistry – A Cross-Disciplinary Journal (CMC) has gone from project to a fully constituted international Diamond Open Access journal, ready to publish. Its scope, boards, peer-review workflow, author guidelines, publishing platform and five-year business model are in place, and it has been presented to the Belgian and European open-access community. Renewed support will carry CMC through its first issue and published articles, the step that turns the proof of concept into a functioning journal. The editorial board is currently working on the first issue. First papers are expected for January 2027.

Item

Detail

Full title

Circular Materials and Chemistry – A Cross-Disciplinary Journal

ISSN (electronic)

3118-4529

Model

Diamond Open Access: no APCs for authors, no subscriptions for readers, CC-BY licence, non-profit

Scope

Circularity across three pillars: Materials and Processes, Economy, Society

Language

English

Platforms

Dissemination on PoPuPS (ULiège Library, Lodel); submission and review on OJS

Origin

Work Package 2A of the inter-university FWB-CoARA project (Jan 2024 – Jun 2025), coordinated at ULiège by ULiège Library

Main activities, 2024–2026

The two years were devoted to building the journal to international standards and making it known; no issue has been published yet. It was necessary to dedicate time to carefully constructing an international editorial board, as well as a vision (Aims and Scope) that was collectively developed by the board.

Date

Activity

Outcome

May 2026

Presentation at Challenges of Contemporary Publishing, Lublin (Poland)

CMC presented internationally as a proof-of-concept journal leading to a Belgian Diamond OA foundation

Nov 2025

Dedicated CMC section on PINDARE, the FWB inter-university research platform (CRef)

Permanent visibility for all FWB researchers, with an explainer on the Diamond OA model

3 Jun 2025

DIAMAS closing event, Royal Library, Brussels

Poster presentation; connection with the European Diamond OA ecosystem

22 May 2025

FWB-CoARA closing event, UNamur (150+ participants)

First public presentation of CMC; first in-person meeting of the boards; roundtable on Diamond OA with UNESCO, CNRS, DIAMAS and BELSPO

Feb 2025

International call for board members relayed through the UNIC university alliance and WBI networks

Recruitment of non-Belgian experts for the boards

2024–2025

Design of the journal with eight FWB researchers in circularity

Scope, three article types (research articles, perspectives and comments, reviews), author guidelines, ethics statement, peer-review workflow, platform choice, five-year business model

Governance and editorial quality

CMC now has two international boards totaling 22 researchers from about 15 institutions in 7 countries, and a peer-review model built for quality and transparency (Governance). By mid-2026, one of the most active members of the CMC editorial board had resigned from his position due to a significant change in his professional circumstances. This prompted CMC to recruit a new board member, which was accomplished by September 2026. This situation caused a delay to the first issue of the journal, which was originally planned for the first half of 2026.

Body

Members

Composition

Editorial Board

6

Chief Editor Éric Pirard (ULiège); Vice-Chief Editor Philippe Nimmegeers (UAntwerpen); Associate Editors from CNRS, UMONS and ULiège/Gembloux Agro-Bio Tech

Advisory Board

16

Belgium, France, Germany, China, Australia and the USA, including IFP Énergies nouvelles, KU Leuven, Tufts and Curtin University and University of Aalto; acts as reviewer pool and international relay

Key quality and open-science features validated by the board:

  • Peer review: at least two reviewers; ethics, plagiarism and AI screening within 15 days; a choice between single-blind and open review, with reviewer reports and author responses published with a DOI (Peer review).

  • Open science: DOI-registered preprints, community comments through Hypothesis for ORCID-identified researchers, and mandatory deposit of the underlying data in a public repository.

  • Ethics and slow science: a strict conflict-of-interest policy and a stated priority for quality over volume (Open Science and Slow Science).

  • Infrastructure at no cost: PoPuPS (ULiège Library, about 30 Diamond OA journals) provides the platform and IT support for Lodel and OJS free of charge.

Financial report

Most of CMC’s costs are still covered by ULiège Library and the University of Liège: two thirds of the editorial office staff and all other costs. Funders support the remaining third of the staff (about 0.17 FTE).

Cost item

ULiège Library / University of Liège

Funders' support

Editorial office staff (0.5 FTE)

2/3 (≈ 0.33 FTE)

1/3 (≈ 0.17 FTE)

Office room and computer equipment

100%

–

Travel costs

100%

–

IT support

100%

–

Publishing platform (PoPuPS) and software (OJS)

100%

–

Funding, outlook and request for renewal

The funding for 2024–2026 was primarily allocated to partially support the CMC editorial office, specifically one third of the editorial manager position (about 0.17 of 0.5 FTE). The other two thirds of this position, and all other costs, continue to be provided by ULiège Library (see Financial report). A high-quality editorial office is pivotal for shaping and bolstering an internationally recognised Diamond OA journal.

CMC is therefore asking its funders to renew their support, in order to publish its first two issues in 2027 and secure the journal’s long-term financing. The funds collected will primarily support the editorial office, ideally increasing their current share of one third of the 0.5 FTE position (about 0.17 FTE) to two thirds.

Funding model. A five-year business model combines direct institutional funding, research foundations and a donation programme for university libraries (Ally €3,000, Protector €5,000, Guardian €10,000 per year). All FWB university libraries have agreed to support CMC, and talks with other libraries are under way. Seven institutions currently contribute €34,500 per year:

Category

Supporters

Per year

Guardian

CNRS

€10,000

Protector

F.R.S.-FNRS (€7,500); ULiège Library (€5,000)

€12,500

Ally

UCLouvain, ULB, UMONS and UNamur libraries (€3,000 each)

€12,000

Total

7 supporters

€34,500

Structural step. CMC has led to a wider project: a Belgian Royal Foundation for Diamond Open Access, backed by Belgian Diamond OA institutions and international partners, to hold the journal's legal ownership, stabilise its finances and later support other Diamond OA journals.

Why it matters. International, high-quality Diamond OA journals remain rare in STM, and most circularity journals are commercial Gold OA titles. CMC demonstrates a non-profit alternative governed by researchers.

Short-Term and Long-Term Objectives

Objectives for 2027

  • First issue: published in spring 2027;

  • Second issue: published in fall 2027.

Five-year objectives

  1. Publish 100 articles per year, which will allow CMC to be considered a superior-size Diamond OA journal;

  2. Obtain DOAJ listing and indexing in major databases once the first articles are out;

  3. Widen and diversify funding beyond the FWB libraries. We will apply for subsidies from KOALA in Germany, COUPERIN in France, and the Open Journal Collective in the UK;

  4. Strengthen the Economy and Society pillars on the boards and continue to promote CMC at Diamond OA events. This will mainly involve welcoming articles encompassing interdisciplinary approaches (combining the pillars), and after a few issues, widening the recruitment of board members to include the social sciences. The editorial board first decided to publish the initial issues with the existing editorial office.